Must Read Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

Must Read Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

Move over PSL, these new fiction books are what's trending this fall. Find the best new book for your book club and fun, fall food and drink pairings. 

If you or your book club are looking for new fall reads to spice up your discussions, you've come to the right place. Fall is the perfect time to curl up with a good book and indulge in the cozy atmosphere that the season brings. Whether you're a fan of thrilling mysteries, heartwarming friendships, thought-provoking dramas, or captivating historical fiction, the options are endless.

We've pulled together some of our favorite picks for each of these book club themes:

  • Literary fiction
  • Women's fiction
  • Historical fiction
  • Thrillers and mysteries
  • World literature
  • Friendship fiction

And as always, our editors at Page & Pairing have discovered delicious, fall food and drink pairings for each category.

Save 20% off any of our fall preview titles from our friends at Tertulia using the promo code PAIRING. Plus, club members can get 50% off + free shipping on their first book with a Tertulia trial membership.

New Thriller and Mystery Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

There's something about the chilling air and the anticipation of Halloween that makes diving into a gripping mystery novel all the more exciting. From psychological thrillers to classic whodunits, there are plenty of options to choose from that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

Fall Steak Kabobs with Apple Cider Marinade

from Raising Whasians

Apple cider marinade for steak Fall Steak Kabobs with Apple Cider Marinade | Delicious fall grilling recipe featuring steak, sweet potatoes & easy apple cider marinade #ProteinChallenge #Recipe #grilling

Smoky Harvest Apple Cider Margarita

from Tieghan Gerard

side angled photo of Smoky Harvest Apple Cider Margarita with smoking cinnamon stick

The Future by Naomi Alderman

isbn: 9781668025680,template: listThe bestselling, award-winning author of The Power delivers a dazzling tour de force where a handful of friends plot a daring heist to save the world from the tech giants whose greed threatens life as we know it.

What We Kept to Ourselves by Nancy Jooyoun Kim

isbn: 9781668004821,template: listThe New York Times bestselling author of the Reese's Book Club pick The Last Story of Mina Lee returns with a timely and surprising new novel about a family's search for answers following the disappearance of their mother.

The Leftover Woman by Jean Kwok

isbn: 9780063031463,template: list

An evocative family drama and a riveting mystery about the ferocious pull of motherhood for two very different women--from the New York Times bestselling author of Searching for Sylvie Lee and Girl in Translation.

Midnight Is the Darkest Hour by Ashley Winstead

isbn: 9781728269962,template: listFrom the critically acclaimed author of In My Dreams I Hold A Knife and The Last Housewife comes Midnight is the Darkest Hour, a gothic Southern thriller about a killer haunting a small Louisiana town, where two outcasts--the preacher's daughter and the boy from the wrong side of the tracks--hold the key to uncovering the truth.

The Unmaking of June Farrow by Adrienne Young

isbn: 9780593598672,template: listA woman risks everything to end her family's centuries-old curse, solve her mother's disappearance, and find love in this mesmerizing novel from the New York Times bestselling author of Spells for Forgetting.

Penance by Eliza Clark

isbn: 9780063327856,template: listFrom the author of the cult hit Boy Parts comes a chilling, brilliantly told story of murder among a group of teenage girls--a powerful and disturbing novel as piercing in its portrait of young women as Emma Cline's The Girls.

Here in the Dark by Alexis Soloski

isbn: 9781250882943,template: listA dark and stylish novel of psychological suspense about a young theater critic drawn into a dangerous game that blurs the lines between reality and performance.

The Beautiful and the Wild by Peggy Townsend

isbn: 9780593638088,template: listThe dangers of Alaska aren't limited to storms, starvation, and grizzly bears. Sometimes the most dangerous thing is the person you love.

New Literary Fiction Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

If you're in the mood for something more thought-provoking, fall is the perfect time to dive into a drama or literary fiction novel. These genres often explore complex themes and offer deep insights into the human condition. From exploring moral dilemmas to examining societal issues, these books are sure to spark intense discussions and provide ample material for your book club meetings.

Cranberry Brie Bites

from Yellow Bliss Road

an overhead image of cranberry brie bites on a wooden platter with fresh rosemary

Applejack Rabbit

from Liquor.com

hands express lemon peel oils over the Applejack Rabbit cocktail, served in a coupe glass

Land of Milk and Honey by C Pam Zhang

isbn: 9780593538241,template: listThe award-winning author of How Much of These Hills Is Gold returns with a rapturous and revelatory novel about a young chef whose discovery of pleasure alters her life and, indirectly, the world.

People Collide by Isle McElroy

isbn: 9780063283756,template: listFrom the acclaimed author of The Atmospherians--"a Fight Club for the Millennial Generation" (Mat Johnson)--a gender-bending, body-switching novel that explores marriage, identity, and sex, and raises profound questions about the nature of true partnership.

Death Valley by Melissa Broder

isbn: 9781668024843,template: listThe most profound book yet from the visionary author of Milk Fed and The Pisces, a darkly funny novel about grief that becomes a desert survival story.

The Future Future by Adam Thirlwell

isbn: 9780374607616,template: listA wild story of female friendship, language, and power, from France to colonial America to the moon, from 1775 to this very moment: a historical novel like no other.

Julia by Sandra Newman

isbn: 9780063265332,template: listAn imaginative, feminist, and brilliantly relevant-to-today retelling of Orwell's 1984, from the point of view of Winston Smith's lover, Julia, by critically acclaimed novelist Sandra Newman.

Before We Say Goodbye by Toshikazu Kawaguchi

isbn: 9781335009111,template: listThe fourth novel in the internationally bestselling Before the Coffee Gets Cold Series – Featuring signature heartwarming characters and wistful storytelling, in the beautifully haunting Before We Say Goodbye, Kawaguchi asks: Who would you visit if you could travel through time?

Normal Rules Don't Apply: Stories by Kate Atkinson

isbn: 9780385549509,template: listA dazzling collection of eleven interconnected stories from the bestselling, award-winning author of Shrines of Gaiety and Life After Life, with everything that readers love about her novels--the inventiveness, the verbal felicity, the sharp observations on human nature, and the deeply satisfying emotional wallop.

The Breakaway by Jennifer Weiner

isbn: 9781668033425,template: listFrom #1 New York Times bestselling author Jennifer Weiner comes a warmhearted and empowering new novel about love, family, friendship, secrets, and a life-changing journey.

New Women's Fiction Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

With a diverse array of voices and perspectives, these books spark meaningful dialogues on identity and empowerment that resonate deeply. Choose a women's fiction book and embark on a literary adventure that not only entertains but also enlightens, making your book club gatherings truly unforgettable.

Maple Candied Pecans

from A Latte Food

maple candied nuts on baking tray

Apple Pie Cocktail

from Jennifer Meyering

Apple Pie Cocktail

The Vaster Wilds by Lauren Groff

isbn: 9780593418390,template: listA taut and electrifying novel from celebrated bestselling author Lauren Groff, about one spirited girl alone in the wilderness, trying to survive.

The Book of Ayn by Lexi Freiman

isbn: 9781646221929,template: listAn original and hilarious satire of both our political culture and those who rage against it, The Book of Ayn follows a writer from New York to Los Angeles to Lesbos as she searches for artistic and spiritual fulfillment in radical selfishness, altruism, and ego-death.

Yours for the Taking by Gabrielle Korn

isbn: 9781250283368,template: listThe year is 2050. Ava and her girlfriend live in what's left of Brooklyn, and though they love each other, it's hard to find happiness while the effects of climate change rapidly eclipse their world. Soon, it won't be safe outside at all. The only people guaranteed survival are the ones whose applications are accepted to The Inside Project, a series of weather-safe, city-sized structures around the world.

Mary and the Birth of Frankenstein by Anne Eekhout

isbn: 9780063256743,template: listAn intensely gripping reimagining of Mary Shelley's youth, vividly exploring innocence, young love, gothic mystery and the roots of her literary masterpiece, Frankenstein.

Welcome Home, Stranger by Kate Christensen

isbn: 9780063299702,template: list

From the PEN-Faulkner Award-winning author of The Great Man comes a novel about grief, love, growing older, and the complications of family that is the story of a fifty-something woman who goes home--reluctantly--to Maine after the death of her mother.

This Is Salvaged: Stories by Vauhini Vara

isbn: 9780393541731,template: listPushing intimacy to its limits in prose of unearthly beauty, Vauhini Vara explores the nature of being a child, parent, friend, sibling, neighbor, or lover, and the relationships between self and others. 

New Historical Fiction Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

For history buffs, fall is also a great time to delve into the world of historical fiction. These novels transport you to different eras and allow you to immerse yourself in richly detailed settings. Whether you're interested in ancient civilizations or the World Wars, there's a historical fiction novel out there that will transport you and your fellow readers back in time.

Old Fashioned Butterscotch Cake

from Julie Blanner

A slice of butterscotch cake on a white plate.

Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned

from Tieghan Gerard

close up photo of Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned

Let Us Descend by Jesmyn Ward

isbn: 9781982104498,template: listFrom Jesmyn Ward--the two-time National Book Award winner, youngest winner of the Library of Congress Prize for Fiction, and MacArthur Fellow--comes a haunting masterpiece, sure to be an instant classic, about an enslaved girl in the years before the Civil War.

The Wildest Sun by Asha Lemmie

isbn: 9780593185711,template: listFollowing her New York Times bestselling debut Fifty Words for Rain, Asha Lemmie's next sweeping and evocative novel introduces a determined young woman's search for the larger-than-life literary figure she believes to be her father.

Absolution by Alice McDermott

isbn: 9780374610487,template: listA riveting account of women's lives on the margins of the Vietnam War, from the renowned winner of the National Book Award.

The House of Doors by Tan Twan Eng

isbn: 9781639731930,template: listFrom the bestselling author of The Garden of Evening Mists, a spellbinding novel about love and betrayal, colonialism and revolution, storytelling and redemption.

True Account: Hannah Masury's Sojourn Amongst the Pyrates, Written by Herself by Katherine Howe

isbn: 9781250304889,template: listFrom New York Times bestselling author Katherine Howe comes a daring first-hand account of one young woman's unbelievable adventure as one of the most terrifying sea rovers of all time.

The Fraud by Zadie Smith

isbn: 9780525558965,template: listFrom acclaimed and bestselling novelist Zadie Smith, a kaleidoscopic work of historical fiction set against the legal trial that divided Victorian England, about who gets to tell their story--and who gets to be believed.

Her Own Revolution: Book 2 of the Château de Verzat series by Debra Borchert

isbn: 9780989454575,template: listA Woman Forges a Treacherous Path to Save Hundreds from the Guillotine

Geneviève Fouquier-Tinville dresses like a man to attend a forbidden university and convinces her father to hire her as a court clerk. She saves Louis LaGarde's life while copying lists of names scheduled for execution, but must face the truth of her own heart. She fights for her life and the lives of those she's come to love. Sponsored

 

New Friendship Fiction Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

Unite your group through shared laughter, tears, and insights as you embark on a meaningful journey into the heart and profound bonds of friendship. When you choose a book with friendship as its core theme, it adds a layer of relatability that readers from all walks of life will love.

Sweet Potato Goat Cheese Appetizer

from Deb Attinella

sweet potato appetizer on plate with honey drizzle

Sidecar Cocktail

by Erin Merhar

sidecar cocktail recipe

Rebecca, Not Becky by Christine Platt - Catherine Wigginton Greene

isbn: 9780063213593,template: listIn the vein of Such a Fun Age, a whip-smart, compulsively readable novel about two upper-class stay-at-home mothers--one white, one Black--living in a "perfect" suburb that explores motherhood, friendship, and the true meaning of sisterhood amidst the backdrop of America's all-too-familiar racial reckoning.

Lies and Other Love Languages by Sonali Dev

isbn: 9781662513978,template: listFrom the bestselling author of The Vibrant Years comes an emotional story of three women navigating ugly truths and safe lies with only love to guide them on a journey of motherhood, friendship, and life.

The Vulnerables by Sigrid Nunez

isbn: 9780593715512,template: listThe New York Times-bestselling, National Book Award-winning author of The Friend and What Are You Going Through brings her singular voice to a story about modern life and connection.

City People by Elizabeth Topp

isbn: 9781662507335,template: listFrom Perfectly Impossible author Elizabeth Topp comes an unforgettably searing novel about a band of mothers who are forced to reckon with themselves after the unexpected loss of one of their own.

The Happy Couple by Naoise Dolan

isbn: 9780063330467,template: listINTERNATIONAL BESTSELLER – An intimate, sharply funny novel about a couple heading toward their wedding, and the three friends who may draw them apart.

Everything Is Not Enough by Lola Akinmade Akerstrom

isbn: 9780063316973,template: listFrom Lola Akinmade Åkerström, international bestselling author of In Every Mirror She's Black, comes the highly anticipated second novel, focusing on the lives of three Black women as they fight their own personal struggles in one of the most egalitarian societies, Sweden.

 

New World literature fiction Book Club Picks for Fall 2023

Transport your book club to a world of literary diversity and cultural richness by selecting a captivating book penned by an international author. Immerse yourselves in the vivid tapestry of new landscapes, traditions, and perspectives, as you embark on a reading voyage that transcends borders.

Canadian Butter Tarts

from Jessica Formicola

overhead shot of pile of butter tarts with text overlay for facebook

Hard Cider Sangria

from Grace Parisi

Hard Cider Sangria

The Premonition by Banana Yoshimoto - Asa Yoneda

isbn: 9781640093713,template: listThe internationally beloved author of Kitchen and Dead-End Memories returns with a beautiful and heartfelt story of a young woman haunted by her childhood and the inescapable bitterness that inevitably comes from knowing the truth.

My Work by Olga Ravn - Russell Russell

isbn: 9780811234719,template: list

My Work is a novel about the unique and fundamental experience of giving birth, mixing different literary forms--fiction, essay, poetry, memoir, and letters--to explore the relationship between motherhood, work, individuality, and literature."Olga Ravn writes dazzlingly about the work of motherhood and the work of writing. Reading Ravn's book, you run through the whole gamut of human emotion, as though you too were a new mother: tears, laughter, anger, fear, pain, frustration. This is powerful writing that's hard to put down."--Politiken

Vengeance Is Mine by Marie Ndiaye - Jordan Stump

isbn: 9780593534243,template: listFrom the best-selling author of Three Strong Women comes a thrilling novel about a triple homicide that dredges up unsettling memories from a lawyer's childhood.

The Children's Bach by Helen Garner - Rumaan Alam

isbn: 9780553387414,template: listNow in a new edition with a foreword by Rumaan Alam, a modern classic from one of Australia's greatest writers

A Grandmother Begins the Story by Michelle Porter

isbn: 9781643755182,template: listAward-winning author Michelle Porter makes her fiction debut with an enchanting and original story of the unrivaled desire for healing and the power of familial bonds across five generations of Métis women and the land and bison that surround them.

Tremor by Teju Cole

isbn: 9780812997118,template: listA powerful, intimate novel that masterfully explores what constitutes a meaningful life in a violent world--from the award-winning author of Open City.

Roman Stories by Jhumpa Lahiri 

isbn: 9780593536322,template: listThe first short story collection by the Pulitzer Prize-winning author and master of the form since her number one New York Times bestseller Unaccustomed Earth - Rome--metropolis and monument, suspended between past and future, multi-faceted and metaphysical--is the protagonist, not the setting, of these nine stories.

The Last Island: Discovery, Defiance, and the Most Elusive Tribe on Earth by Adam Goodheart

isbn: 9781567926828,template: list

A journey to the coast of North Sentinel Island, home to a tribe believed to be the most isolated human community on earth. The Sentinelese people want to be left alone and will shoot deadly arrows at anyone who tries to come ashore. As the web of modernity draws ever closer, the island represents the last chapter in the Age of Discovery--the final holdout in a completely connected world. Sponsored

 

 

Discover the captivating world of women's, historical, thriller, friendship, and world fiction books, and elevate your book club experience to new heights. Immerse yourselves in rich narratives that ignite thought-provoking conversations that transcend the pages.

Stay up-to-date on all our Page & Pairing recommendations through our weekly newsletter.

  • We participate in affiliate advertising programs. Links to affiliate partners are commission-earning.
  • © 2025 Bookfinity. All rights reserved.