Regardless of where you stand on the subject of past lives, Maggie Mackay may make a believer out of you in Carole Johnstone’s ever-atmospheric gothic novel, The Blackhouse. As a child, Maggie claimed to be the reincarnation of Andrew MacNeil, dead by murder — or so says Maggie of this mysterious man. When she returns as an adult to the small Scotland town on the island of Kilmeray, with a few secrets in her back pocket, the locals are wary. As Maggie starts digging into the town’s history in order to get to the bottom of Andrew’s story, another unexpected figure comes to light. As the author reveals the 25-year-old story of Robert, revealing eerie twists and turns all along, you’ll be properly spooked — and likely love every minute of it.
The Blackhouse
by Carole Johnstone

![]() | ![]() |
| True Myth Cabernet Sauvignon | Attems Pinot Grigio |
| For this week’s red wine pick, we’re inspired by the fog of secrecy that hovers over truth in The Blackhouse with this True Myth Cabernet Sauvignon. Expect a ton of dark-fruited depth in this bottle, with just a touch of pepper. It’s as moody as the novel and would feel very much at home in the coziest corner of Blackhouse. | Maggie finds fast friends in bartender Gillian and Blackhouse host Kelly. Her time with them is slightly soaked in Pinot Grigio. We’re not sure what they’re pouring at the pub, but we’d hope it’s something like this Attems Pinot Grigio, which is sort of subtly complex in its structure — and oh so drinkable. We think it pairs perfectly with uncomfortable moments, though we would much prefer to enjoy it while at ease. |

Sausage and Potato Soup
From Yummy Toddler Food by Amy Palanjian
We initially went looking for a stovie recipe to pair with this novel but then played witness to the Italian-adjacent dinner Kelly “cooks” for Maggie. From there, we were pulled into this Sausage and Potato Soup, which sits squarely between the two. Best of all, it’s as simple as it is delicious.

INGREDIENTS
|
STEPS
NOTES
SLOW-COOKER VERSION
|
| Recipe Copyright © 2023 by Palanjian Media, LLC. Photographs copyright © 2023 by Lauren Volo. |

Eager to dissect and dive deeper into the novel with friends — or just with your own thoughts? Here are some discussion questions to help keep you on track. Only proceed if you’ve finished the novel — spoilers abound!

We asked author Carole Johnstone to share her thoughts on why she thinks Scotland provided the perfect setting for her novel. What is it about the country that lends itself to such an eerie, atmospheric type of tale? She didn’t

If you’re anything like us, the moment you finish The Blackhouse (and after getting yourself a copy of Carole’s previous novel, Mirrorland), you’ll be eager to dig into even more Scotland literature. Who better to provide those recommendations than the author? Check out Carole’s Scotland reading list for a little guidance on where to go next.


