This Month’s Reads & Pairings: Mystery, Romance and Seasonal Pairings
December has arrived, and the Page & Pairing editors are kicking off the season with our most festive stack of staff picks yet. Leading the lineup is Ally Carter’s The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year, a sparkling mystery perfect for sleuthing under twinkle lights. From there, we’re diving into more can't-put-down whodunits, a hint of romance, and a touch of literary fiction to round out your winter reading mood.
And because the holidays are all about cozy details, we’ve paired each pick with seasonal joy—from sip-worthy beverages to curated playlists that set the perfect vibe. Whether you're settling in by a crackling fire or sneaking in a chapter between celebrations, these December selections are here to bring warmth, wonder, and a little sprinkle of seasonal cheer to your TBR.
Taylor's December Read
"My coworker and fellow editor, Alex, recommended this book for light holiday reading.
Normally I am not an enemies-to lovers romance enthusiast but with the added mystery and seasonal theme, I couldn't resist. This was a perfect read and will continue the kind deed of further passing this along as a recommendation!"
The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year
By Ally Carter
A Wonderful Life Cocktail
Iced Ginger "Biscuits"
Alex's December Read
"I wanted mystery and this book gives you mystery. Everyone seems to have a reason to have committed murder and Christine, an editor for Bespoke Weddings, is on the case (not intentionally). Taking place in Ireland, these pairings really gives off the immersive experience. If you are a fan of Knives Out, you will love this!"
A Killer Wedding
By Joan O'Leary
Jameson Irish Mule
Guinness Chocolate Cake
Jane's December Read
"Time-slip mystery set on a stormy New England island prone to shipwrecks? Count me in!
This is a satisfying pick for fans of juicy women's fiction who like stories with salt air, hidden art, and tangled family legacies. The three-timeline thread occasionally slows the momentum (especially the modern day ones), but it resolves with Williams' trademark flair for layered relationships.
Since it's now the holiday season, the pairings will add some warmth to December's nights."
Under the Stars
By Beatriz Williams
Buttered Rum Mocktail
Spotify She & Him Christmas
Shannon's December Read
"Finally made it to this gem on my TBR list! After seeing the reading guide on Page & Pairing, I went rogue and wanted to add some additional pairings for the holiday season.
Against the beautiful backdrop of Puget Sound, the sole survivor of her small family, Tova, finds unlikely friends in the curmudgeonly octopus, Marcellus, and Cameron. This heartwarming story with an undercurrent of mystery would be the perfect read to cozy up with during this holiday season."
Remarkably Bright Creatures
By Shelby Van Pelt
Boozy Wassail
Scones - Variety